Published on: 15/10/2026
This new ALMASI output, “Comparative Analysis of Quality Support Instruments and Evaluation Systems”, compares twelve international organisations and indexes, and groups 46 countries across Africa, Latin America and Europe into five clusters based on their journal and researcher evaluation policies.
Its main finding is that commercial databases remain the de facto global benchmark, and that open infrastructure and journal-level reforms often coexist, sometimes uneasily, alongside researcher incentives that typically reward commercial indexation.
It argues that quality-support instruments should aim to build editorial capacity rather than gatekeep, and that Diamond OA status and editorial quality should be treated as separate questions. The analysis is based on desk research and interpretive coding, so the clusters should be read as indicative rather than definitive. The report will inform the twinning and mutual learning work in the next phase of the project.